Mechanical keyboards can feature different switch mounts methods, primarily plate-mounted and PCB-mounted. These mounting styles impact the keyboard’s construction, feel, and overall typing experience. Let’s thoroughly analyze and compare these two types.
Plate-Mounted Switches
Description: In plate-mounted keyboards, the switches are mounted to a metal or plastic plate which then sits above the PCB (Printed Circuit Board). This plate adds an extra layer of rigidity and stability.
Pros:
- Stability and Rigidity: The plate provides additional support, making the keyboard feel more solid and stable.
- Typing Feel: Often results in a more consistent and firmer typing feel.
- Durability: Adds structural integrity to the keyboard, potentially enhancing durability.
- Sound: This can alter the sound profile of typing, often resulting in a more resonant and “fuller” sound.
Cons:
- Weight: Adds extra weight to the keyboard, making it heavier.
- Flexibility: Reduces the flex of the PCB, leading to a less ‘bouncy’ typing experience.
- Customization and Repair: Swapping switches can be more challenging and may require desoldering.
PCB-Mounted Switches
Description: PCB-mounted switches are directly mounted to the keyboard’s PCB. In this design, there is no supporting plate between the switches and the PCB.
Pros:
- Flexibility: The lack of a plate can allow the PCB to flex more, which some typists prefer for its unique feel.
- Weight: Generally lighter than plate-mounted keyboards.
- Customization and Repair: Easier to customize and repair as the switches can often be removed without desoldering (especially if the keyboard supports hot-swapping).
- Sound: Tends to produce a softer, less resonant typing sound compared to plate-mounted switches.
Cons:
- Stability: Without the plate, the keyboard can feel less stable and robust.
- Typing Feel: This may result in a less consistent feel across the keyboard, especially on larger keys.
- Durability: Potentially less durable due to the lack of additional support from a plate.
Comparison and Analysis
- Typing Experience: Plate-mounted switches typically provide a more consistent and stable typing experience, while PCB-mounted switches offer a unique, slightly more flexible feel.
- Sound Profile: Plate mounting often results in a louder, more solid sound, whereas PCB mounting tends to be quieter and softer.
- Construction and Durability: Plate-mounted keyboards are generally more robust and durable, while PCB-mounted keyboards are lighter and offer easier access for modifications.
- User Preference: The choice between plate and PCB mounting often comes down to personal preference. Gamers and professionals might prefer the solid feel of plate-mounted keyboards, while enthusiasts and typists who enjoy a softer, more dynamic typing experience may lean toward PCB-mounted options.
- Customization: PCB-mounted keyboards are typically more conducive to customization, especially for users who frequently change switches.
In summary, the choice between plate-mounted and PCB-mounted switches in a mechanical keyboard significantly affects the typing experience, sound, durability, and customization options. While plate-mounted keyboards offer stability and a consistent typing feel, PCB-mounted keyboards provide flexibility and easier customization. The preference for one over the other is subjective and largely depends on the individual’s typing style and priorities.
For more knowledge of mechanical keyboards, check DURGOD.
